As Randy’s Donuts enters Japan’s competitive doughnut market, the company is using a large-scale marketing tactic: a giant doughnut. The 32-foot doughnut, which sits atop their Inglewood, California location, is becoming a key part of their strategy as they prepare to open up to 50 outlets across Japan.
Mark Kelegian, president and CEO of Randy’s Donuts, explained the attraction: “Everyone loves pictures of themselves with the big doughnut.” The doughnut has become an iconic symbol, often featured in movies like Mars Attacks, Get Shorty, 2012, and Iron Man 2. It is also believed to have inspired The Simpsons’ Lard Lad Donuts.
While Randy’s plans to place a giant doughnut at each Japanese store, Kelegian notes that space constraints may limit this in some locations. “Where we cannot do that, we aim to have the biggest doughnut possible on the building or the ground,” he said.
However, success in Japan is no guarantee. Many American brands have struggled in the Japanese market. Companies like Walmart, Subway, and American Eagle have faced difficulties. Even Dunkin’ Donuts, which entered Japan in 1970, eventually left in the late 1990s, though a few locations remain on U.S. military bases.
Japan’s doughnut market is especially competitive. Local chains like Mister Donut have been around for decades, and newer brands like I’m Donut have become trendy favorites. Supermarkets and convenience stores also sell doughnuts, while Japan’s diverse range of local snacks competes for attention.
Japan’s consumers are known for their discerning tastes, and getting their attention is a challenge. Shinichi Murakami, a market entry expert, explained, “Japan’s food sector is highly saturated, with strong domestic players and foreign competitors fighting for consumer attention.” Florian Kohlbacher, a Japan-based executive, added that doughnut success depends on how much value a brand adds beyond the basic product.
Some American brands have succeeded by adapting to local preferences. Starbucks and McDonald’s are prime examples, and Krispy Kreme has found success with nearly 50 locations in Japan. Some brands have even thrived in Japan while closing down in the U.S., such as Dean & Deluca and The City Bakery.
Randy’s Donuts, founded in 1952, was acquired by Kelegian in 2015. Since then, the company has aggressively expanded, both domestically and internationally. Randy’s has opened locations in the Philippines, Saudi Arabia, South Korea, and is now eyeing Japan. In South Korea, their waterfront location, complete with a giant doughnut, has become a popular Instagram spot.
The company is learning from its South Korean stores, particularly how to attract younger crowds. Randy’s Donuts has built a strong reputation in the U.S. for its diverse selection and quality doughnuts. Kelegian emphasized the importance of adapting to local markets while maintaining the brand’s American roots: “We want to be a part of the country’s fabric, not just a USA brand inserted into the market.”
Krispy Kreme’s experience in Japan highlights the unpredictable nature of the market. Initially met with skepticism over its sweetness, Krispy Kreme eventually became successful by adjusting its offerings to better suit local tastes.
The key challenge for Randy’s, like other brands, will be to strike a balance between adaptation and maintaining its core identity. According to Kohlbacher, “The question for companies entering Japan is how much we need to adapt while staying true to ourselves.”
A giant doughnut might draw crowds initially, but sustaining long-term success requires more than just novelty. “Most brands get a boost when they first come. They become a craze. Making a sustainable business is harder,” cautions W. David Marx, author of Ametora: How Japan Saved American Style.
The future of Randy’s Donuts in Japan depends on whether the brand can truly integrate into Japanese culture. Nico Prinsloo, founder of Donut Info, suggests that the doughnut market can offer a glimpse into Japan’s evolving tastes and preferences.
Whether the giant doughnut becomes a permanent fixture in Japan’s food scene remains to be seen, but it’s clear that Randy’s Donuts is aiming to make a lasting impact with a mix of iconic branding and strategic adaptation.
Related Topics: