To indulge in a donut from Better Maid Donut in Pittsburgh, an early wake-up is essential. This popular Crafton Heights spot is famed for its limited production and dedicated fans who eagerly wait up to half an hour for their sought-after pastries. Due to this high demand, Better Maid Donut often sells out within an hour of its ~6:30 a.m. weekday and ~7:30 a.m. weekend openings.
Operating Hours and Updates
The hours listed on Google may not always be accurate. Recent reports suggest the shop sometimes opens at 6:45 a.m., but this can vary. For the most reliable updates, check Better Maid Donut’s Instagram, particularly their Instagram Stories.
A Quest for Donuts
Despite my aversion to early mornings, I had been attempting to visit Better Maid Donut for nearly two years. It wasn’t until a spring morning, when an early sunrise jolted me awake, that I saw my chance.
Finding Better Maid Donut
On the day of my visit, I nearly forgot about Better Maid Donut due to my early start. By the time I remembered, it was nearly 7:30 a.m., and I hurried out the door without even telling Angie, who was still asleep.
Upon arrival, it was clear I had reached the right place. The small, unassuming white house, lacking any visible signs, only had a neon “Open” sign and a line of about twenty people winding around the building.
Why the Fuss?
While waiting in line, I chatted with fellow patrons about their favorite donuts. I learned that Better Maid Donut’s cakes are fried longer than usual, giving them a crispier exterior while maintaining a fluffy interior. This unique texture is a key reason for their loyal customer base.
The shop’s limited production is intentional, balancing profitability with exclusivity. The owner is known for his comment that the last donut is his favorite, and he carefully monitors inventory to ensure quality over quantity.
A Sweet Deal
After a half-hour wait, I ordered three regular donuts, three filled donuts, and a half-dozen donut holes for a total of $5. The donuts lived up to their reputation. The extra frying created a delightful crispiness, and the filled donuts were light yet flavorful, showcasing the cream, jelly, and chocolate.
The donut holes, in particular, were standout items. They had a light glaze and a slight crust, allowing the pure flavor of the donut to shine.
Visiting Tips
Better Maid Donut is located at 1178 Steuben Street in Crafton Heights and operates on a cash-only basis. Note that their posted hours may change, and they occasionally close unexpectedly. For the latest updates, checking their Instagram is recommended.